Interview scorecards

Score every interview the same way.

Replace gut-feel debriefs with shared criteria, written rationale, and calibration your legal and people partners can trust.

Scorecard capabilities

Structure that interviewers actually finish.

Criteria, rubrics, and calibration without another spreadsheet.

Role-specific criteria

Define the traits that matter for each req — not a generic competency laundry list.

Three scoring scales

Numeric, thumbs or hire-recommendation — pick the scale that fits the round so scores stay comparable across interviewers.

Interviewer calibration

See where interviewers diverge and coach before offers go out.

Blind review modes

Control when evaluators can see each other's scores to reduce bias.

Panel aggregation

Roll panel scores into one decision view with rationale preserved.

Export & audit

Export score history for audits and post-mortems.

Templates

Build scorecards once, reuse everywhere

One template for engineering, one for sales, one for interns. Assign it to the job and every interviewer scores the same criteria on the same scale.

Criteria and question sets per role
Numeric, thumbs, or hire-recommendation scales
Reusable templates shared across jobs
Assign a different scorecard to each job
Calibration

Fairness without slowing the team

Blind until submit, rationale required, and a calibration report that shows who runs hot or cold. Structure reduces affinity bias without taking the decision away from people.

Blind mode hides other reviewers' scores
Job blind mode hides name and photo
Calibration report flags scoring outliers
Every score logged in the audit trail
Where teams use scorecards

From first screen to final round

Use scorecards wherever interviews happen.

Engineering

Engineering & product loops

Keep coding and system-design feedback in one rubric.

  • Numeric scale for system design, thumbs for culture
  • Blind mode hides other scores until you submit
  • Calibration report shows who scores high or low
Campus

Campus & early career

Train seasonal interviewers on the same criteria.

  • One scorecard assigned to every intern job
  • Recommendation scale keeps cohorts comparable
  • All evaluations roll up on the candidate profile
Leadership

Leadership interviews

Executive panels share a single score model.

  • Written rationale required with each score
  • Moderator team limits who can evaluate
  • Every evaluation lands in the audit log
Scorecard FAQ

How scorecards fit your process

How scorecards fit your interview process.

Yes — criteria and questions are defined per scorecard, and each job gets the scorecard you assign it. Build one for engineering, one for sales, one for interns.

Yes — async and live interview feedback can use the same scorecard templates.

Scores, edits, and decisions are logged for compliance review.

Free-form notes stay available; scorecards add comparable structure on top.

AI screening ranks applicants; scorecards structure human interviews — they complement each other.

On your own roles

Score your next panel this way.

Scorecards, blind mode and interviewer calibration are part of Hireall. See them on your own roles in a 30-minute demo, or start a 14-day trial.

Talk to our team

Tell us about your roles and team size — we'll map Hireall to your hiring process and the plan that fits.

Contact sales Priced per company, not per seat